Step Back in Time at the Hickory Bridge Farm Country Store

There’s something undeniably special about stepping into a place that feels frozen in time. A place where the scent of aged wood mingles with the sweetness of penny candy, where checkerboards sit ready for a game by the iron stove, and every shelf holds a piece of living history. That’s the magic of the Hickory Bridge Farm Country Store, a true turn-of-the-century general store nestled in the scenic countryside of Orrtanna, Pennsylvania.

Unlike so many modern recreations or themed gift shops, the Country Store at Hickory Bridge Farm isn’t a clever reproduction—it’s the real deal. Established in 1978 by William and Grace Newman, the store was born out of a passion for preserving the rich history and spirit of early American life. The Newmans spent over fifteen years collecting genuine artifacts from old general stores across Pennsylvania, eventually curating a one-of-a-kind space that continues to capture the imagination of visitors to this day.

A True Slice of Americana
From the moment you walk through the door, you’ll be transported to a simpler time. The store’s interior is filled with original furnishings and fixtures, including ceiling-high wooden shelves, candy barrels, rolling curtain-front display cases, and a fully intact post office setup—complete with vintage mail slots and a money order window. These pieces were not purchased from antique malls or salvaged for style—they were lovingly rescued from real general stores across the region. 
​
One of the most striking pieces is the checkerboard placed near the cast-iron stove, a nod to the community-centered spirit that once defined small-town life. It's easy to imagine neighbors gathering here to swap stories and pass the time. And yes—many visitors still stop by to play a game or two, just like old times.

Stories in Every Corner
Nearly every item in the store has a story behind it. The two front counters and the towering back shelves came from Bream’s Store in Cashtown, originally founded by David Mickley between 1880 and 1890. A preserved packing crate slat discovered atop those shelves is inscribed with Mickley’s initials, the year 1890, and a whimsical series of doodles including animals, swirls, and even a stag hunt scene—turning even a forgotten board into a historical artifact.

Look up, and you’ll spot a wire strung across the ceiling holding everything from children's stockings to ladies’ shoes and even a vintage “union suit.” Advertisements and signs, such as the iconic “JT” chewing tobacco sign, still hang exactly as they did in their original locations. One of the most charming touches is a slate sign that reads “Eggs 20 cents”—written in chalk around 1920 and never erased.
​
These items were collected with care, not to create a kitschy attraction, but to offer a genuine window into the past. That sense of authenticity is what sets this store apart from typical tourist stops.

Not Just for Show
While many museums and historical sites are purely visual, the Hickory Bridge Farm Country Store invites you to experience history through all the senses. You can taste it in the thick, sweet molasses that still oozes from an antique barrel pump. You can smell it in the sharp cheese available on weekends, sliced fresh behind the original wooden counters. And of course, you can indulge your sweet tooth with real penny candy—some of it still priced at just a penny per piece.

In addition to nostalgic treats, the store sells small-batch sarsaparilla, apple butter, locally made honey, and a modest selection of handmade jewelry and goods. While the items for sale are limited, they serve a greater purpose: helping the store feel like a real, functioning part of the Hickory Bridge experience rather than a gift shop or souvenir stop.

As Mrs. Newman once said, “We didn’t want to get into souvenirs… just a few things to sell would tie it together as a real general store.” And that philosophy is still evident today.

A Natural Fit with Hickory Bridge Farm
The Country Store is an integral part of the larger Hickory Bridge Farm experience. Located on a picturesque property surrounded by rolling hills, the farm is known for its warm hospitality, historic bed & breakfast accommodations, and farm-style dining in a beautifully restored 160-year-old barn.

It’s not unusual for guests to spend an afternoon enjoying a hearty, home-cooked meal in the restaurant, then wander over to the store to browse the antique shelves, sample molasses, or let the kids pick out candy while grandparents reminisce about stores like these from their own childhood.

Throughout the year, the farm also hosts group gatherings, hayrides, and seasonal events that give guests a reason to return again and again. And each time, the Country Store stands ready to welcome visitors with its timeless charm. 

Why People Keep Coming Back
One of the store’s enduring appeals is its quiet resistance to modern trends. It doesn’t need flashy displays, online reviews, or souvenir mugs. Instead, it thrives on authenticity, word-of-mouth, and the sense of wonder it sparks in everyone who visits.

Whether you’re a history buff, a local returning with grandkids, or a traveler stumbling upon a hidden gem, the store offers something rare—a true connection to the past that feels alive and personal. In an age where so much is digital, fast-paced, and disposable, the Hickory Bridge Farm Country Store is a refreshing reminder of the value in preserving our history and traditions.
​
Plan Your Visit
If you’re planning a trip to Gettysburg or exploring the charming byways of Adams County, be sure to carve out time for a visit to Hickory Bridge Farm—and don’t miss the Country Store. It’s located just a short drive from Gettysburg’s town center, and open during regular farm hours. Stop in for a treat, pick up a jar of local honey, or challenge a friend to a quick game of checkers while you soak in the atmosphere.  ​When you dine at Hickory Bridge Farm or have a special event here, the Country Store is a great added experience!

You may come for the nostalgia, but chances are, you’ll leave with much more—a story, a smile, and a deeper appreciation for the simpler things in life.

Step Back in Time at the Hickory Bridge Farm Country Store